Radar Perene / Articles / episode

The defensives lose their tenants — and win them back in three months

Episode

The extreme

The shelter emptied out almost all at once. For months, domestic money had settled into the defensives — power utilities, real estate funds, securities that pay a predictable dividend and don't depend on the economy's mood. In a single month, the investor swapped what protects for what prospers and ran to the cyclicals. The two pillars of defense loosened together, in the same gesture. In numbers: the Cyclical/Non-Cyclical ratio jumped from z -0.19 to 1.17 — a shift of 1.36 deviation, the largest move in the structure — while Utilities/IBOV pulled back from 2.35 to 1.33 and the IFIX gave way from 1.76 to 1.10 against the Ibovespa. Selic at its historic floor of 7.5% a year, the dollar at R$ 2.03.

What happened next

The exit was short-lived. Three months later, in November 2012, the gesture reversed completely: the Cyclical/Non-Cyclical ratio collapsed from 0.38 to -1.39, a retreat of 1.78 deviation, even more abrupt than August's rush. The money pulled its chips off the cyclicals and returned to the shelter, with the Perene Risk Index crossing into risk_off, from 38.8 to 20.6. In February 2013, the defensives were still re-occupied — Utilities/IBOV rose again, from -0.14 to 0.89, in a month when the investor concentrated almost everything in the financial sector (Financials/IBOV at 2.52, a very rare reading). The tenants had come back.

What did not happen

August's emptying was not the end of the defensives. Anyone who read the flight from the shelter as a regime change got the timing wrong: in three months the same sectors were full again. And the rate at its floor did not evict them — on the contrary, it was the low Selic that kept them attractive whenever appetite pulled back. The real change came a year later, and for the opposite reason: in August 2013, with the Selic back to 9.0% a year, IFIX/IBOV plunged to -1.70 and Utilities/IBOV to -2.13. The shelter only emptied out for good when the rate rose — not when it fell.

The honest verdict

The August 2012 reading captured the real rotation, but not its durability. A shift of 1.36 deviation in one month marks a move, not a regime. What evicts the tenant from a defensive is not a passing appetite for risk; it is the cost of money rising — and that one only appeared twelve months later.

Continue reading: The money pulls its chips off the cyclicals · The bet that fits in a single sector · The disguised fixed income loses its charm →

The Radar reads these regimes every day. See today's reading →

Characters: Structure (intermarket) · Flow (risk appetite) · Mood · Dollar