Radar Perene / Articles / episode

The financials leave the table in November 2017 — and the command that never settled

Episode

The extreme

Confidence stayed frozen at the top while, beneath it, capital changed chairs. Two months earlier, banks and credit had taken the lead of the market; now they were collapsing in relative strength, and commodities were back in command. Domestic mood did not notice — it stayed pinned at extreme optimism, at the same point where the month had begun. In numbers: the Financials/IBOV ratio fell 1.69 deviations (z from −0.17 to −1.87), the largest turn of the month; Commodities/IBOV did the reverse (−0.45 to +1.12); the intermarket crossed into neutral (60.44 to 48.58) and the Ânima Index locked at 69.2.

What happened next

Command went to commodities — but its reason changed. In February 2018 they extended the lead (z from 0.77 to 1.63), even as the appetite for internal risk was already plunging (Perene Risk Index from 50.2 to 5.4). In May 2018 the lead became a currency story: commodities in reais jumped +1.74 deviations in a month, with the dollar at R$ 3.6361, while utilities and financials sank. And in November 2018 even that command cooled — commodities in reais lost the front (z from 0.58 to −0.18) and the financials had already returned to leading (Financials/IBOV from 1.37 to 1.52).

What did not happen

The financials did not stay off the table. The November 2017 rotation looked like a clean exit from domestic credit, but by February they were recovering strength (z from 0.01 to 0.58), and a year later they were in command again. Nor was the commodities' command a surge of demand — in May it was currency, not appetite. And optimism did not collapse in the scare: Ânima stayed at the ceiling before yielding.

The honest verdict

The reading got the change of hands right — capital dropped the banks, commodities took back the front. But it read the direction, not the permanence. Command passed from side to side and came back; the chair never settled with a single owner. And the leadership that looked like commodity strength was, in May, the signature of a weaker real.

Continue reading: When the flow moves before the mood · When the currency dictates the harvest · The extreme that yields without turning →

The Radar reads these regimes every day. See today's reading →

Read also: When the currency dictates the harvest: the +1.74 leap the exchange rate wrote

Characters: Structure (intermarket) · Flow (risk appetite) · Mood · Dollar