Radar Perene / Articles / article

Two floors, opposite directions — 2016 and 2022 read on the same axis

Article

The extreme

A market floor always looks the same from the outside: pessimism at the ceiling, prices on the ground. On the inside, two floors can move in opposite directions. In March 2016, capital was already leaving the shelters — banks and cyclicals were coming back to life after the January low. December 2022 did the reverse: it ran for cover, and the entire structure shrank toward the bottom of the scale. In numbers: in 2016 the intermarket rose from 22.43 to 43.29, a third month of improvement, and the cyclical-to-defensive ratio crossed the waterline, from −0.78 to 0.51; in 2022 the intermarket collapsed from 39.79 to 0.17 and the same ratio sank from −0.73 to −1.16.

What happened next

Each floor left a dissonance behind. In 2016, the structure's recomposition came with a mood that overshot: the sentiment index jumped from 51.8 to 95.5, extreme optimism, while the Perene Risk Index only returned to neutral, at 54.0, and the domestic regime stayed defensive, at 37.9. The crowd ran ahead of the structure. In 2022 the opposite happened: while the intermarket was touching the floor, the internal risk axis rose from 25.9 to 37.3 and returned to neutral — a house in the dark on the outside, one room breathing on the inside. And the dollar marked every scene: firm at R$ 3.70 in the relief of 2016, stretched to R$ 5.24 in the contraction of 2022.

What did not happen

The two floors were not symmetrical, and treating them as the same event is misleading. March 2016 was no longer a floor: it was the third month of rising since the January low, and even so the structure read 43.29 — moderate risk-off, far from any normalization. The recovery was not a leap. In 2022, the single point of light, the ratio between commodities in reais and the Ibovespa that improved from −1.10 to −0.33, announced no turn at all: it was raw materials regaining ground while the other lamps went out. The relief of 2016 was not complete, nor was the isolated light of 2022 the start of one.

The honest verdict

An indicator's floor has no fixed shape. What separates a recomposition from a deepening is not the depth of the pessimism, but the direction in which capital moves between the cycle and the shelter. In 2016 it was leaving; in 2022, entering. The same axis, read in both directions, tells entirely different stories.

Continue reading: The floor that wasn't a floor · The house in the dark — December 2022 · Cyclical against defensive →

The Radar reads these regimes every day. See today's reading →

Characters: Structure (intermarket) · Flow (risk appetite) · Dollar · Cyclicals × defensives