Radar Perene / Articles / article

The direction reversed. The gear did not.

Article

The extreme

There is a part in the engine of the Brazilian market that takes no side. It decides who carries the market — the stocks that breathe with the economy, or the ones that pay income while the rest trembles — and it serves one direction as well as the other. In one January, money dropped the cyclicals and took shelter in the defensives, the most violent move on the panel. In numbers: the Cyclical/Non-Cyclical ratio fell from +1.17 to −0.64, a drop of 1.81 standard deviations, while Utilities stretched their lead from +1.71 to +2.93 deviations. Selic at 11.75% a year, the dollar at R$ 4.91.

What rhymes

Two years later, the same part turned the other way. In the year the defenses gave way together, it was the shelters that got evicted: Utilities collapsed from −0.18 to −1.63 deviations and the Cyclical/Non-Cyclical climbed from 0.96 to 1.29. The money that had once fled the cycle was now buying the end most sensitive to it — commodities in dollars leapt from 0.47 to 1.55 against the Ibovespa. Selic now at 15.0% a year, the dollar at R$ 5.34. The mechanism was identical; only the direction of the rotation had reversed.

What did not happen

Neither of the two turns said what the headline suggested. In 2024, the defensive retreat was not panic: structural appetite eased from 89.7 to 50.7 and stopped on neutral ground — a pullback, not a flight. In 2026, the advance of the cyclicals was not a rehabilitation of the domestic producer: commodities in reais went the opposite way from those in dollars, from −1.51 to −2.36 deviations. The difference between the two is the exchange rate. The gear turned; the economy beneath it confirmed neither the fear on one side nor the faith on the other.

The honest verdict

The cyclical↔defensive hinge keeps no memory of its own direction. It turns wherever the regime pushes it, and the direction of the turn describes the month's appetite, not the health of the economy beneath. Two Januaries two years apart used the same part on opposite shifts, and both times the number of the rotation came in larger than the conviction that held it up. The ruler records which way the shift turned. The side, it never chooses.

Continue the story: The anatomy of a sector capitulation · The basement and the roof, a month later →

The Radar reads these regimes every day. See today's reading →

Read also: A sector capitulates. Or is it the ruler that trembles. · The basement went and came back. The roof never noticed.

Characters: Cyclicals × defensives · Structure (intermarket)