Radar Perene / Articles / episode

The imported downgrade of August 2011 — the strength that was only the currency

Episode

The extreme

There was a gain that existed in reais and vanished in dollars — the same asset, the same month, two opposite verdicts. The external axis carried the fiscal tensions of that August, the downgrade that rattled markets abroad; what reached Brazil, however, was not fear. It was a weaker currency disguised as strength. Brazilian commodities seemed to surge against the index; measured in the international benchmark, they had not moved at all. In numbers: the Commodities (R$)/IBOV ratio jumped from a z of 1.06 to 2.67 — the single largest displacement in the structure that month — while the same ratio in dollars retreated from 1.22 to -0.35. The dollar at R$ 1.597 translated into reais a gain that, abroad, did not exist. Oblivious to the contradiction, the Perene Risk Index recomposed itself from 14.8 to 69.2.

What happened next

August's strength did not survive as a fundamental, but the distrust beneath it became the path. In November 2011, the Perene Risk rose still further, from 79.0 to 86.0, while the intermarket structure did the opposite and collapsed from 33.1 to 23.2. Money abandoned the financial sector (Financials/IBOV from -0.27 to -1.20) and ran toward what protects: commodities in reais and utilities. In February 2012 the retreat deepened — intermarket at 22.9, Utilities/IBOV widening from 1.31 to 2.07. Only in August 2012, with the Selic crushed to 7.5% a year, did capital leave the shelter: the Cyclical/Non-Cyclical ratio jumped 1.36 deviations and went back to buying the economy that turns.

What did not happen

The downgrade did not cross the border as fear. Global Risk stood at 51.9 — neutral ground — in August, and stayed neutral (49.3) in November: the systemic contagion the foreign headlines promised never showed up in the engine's metric. And the "strength" of commodities was not strength: measured in dollars, it was born negative, and within six months it had crumbled to -2.17 against the index. Anyone who read the Perene Risk at 69.2 as full confidence ignored that the structure underneath was already pulling back.

The honest verdict

The engine got the diagnosis that mattered right: two rulers with opposite signs denounce currency, not fundamental. But the headline thermometer — the Perene Risk climbing to 69.2, and to 100 the following January — sold a confidence that the internal anatomy had been contradicting for months. When the cover number and the plumbing disagree, it is usually the plumbing that is right.

Continue reading: The European discord of 2011 · The dollar as a regime thermometer · When the thermometers disagree →

The Radar reads these regimes every day. See today's reading →

Characters: Structure (intermarket) · Flow (risk appetite) · Mood · Dollar