Radar Perene / Articles / episode

The optimism that applauded alone — the 29-point jump of October 2013

Episode

The extreme

Brazilian money decided to celebrate — and it celebrated alone. After months lodged in the defensive rooms of the market, domestic capital returned to risk all at once, and appetite took the biggest jump in the whole recent sequence. Abroad, though, no one applauded along: the global axis stayed parked at neutral. In numbers: the Perene Risk Index went from 55.0 to 84.0, crossing into risk_on, while global risk barely moved, at 53.0. Underneath, the cyclicals retook the lead over the defensives (Cyclical/Non-Cyclical from z −0.96 to 0.21) and the banks moved ahead of the broad index (Financials/IBOV from z −0.24 to 0.65), with the dollar in a truce at R$ 2.19.

What happened next

The applause did not survive the summer. In January 2014, three months later, the same appetite that had climbed to 84 collapsed to 24.1 and crossed into risk_off — the sharpest mood swing in the recent record. The defensive shelter that October had emptied was not reoccupied by optimism: it was reoccupied by retreat, with the utilities handing back the entire lead and the banks sinking (Financials/IBOV at z −0.96). The following year would ride that seesaw. In October 2014, appetite would make the reverse trip, from 14.1 to 92.9 in two months — an amplitude that says more about the violence of the swings than about conviction in any one of them.

What did not happen

October's jump did not announce a bull cycle. Anyone who read the biggest advance in appetite as confirmation of a trend would have bought the top of a homegrown bounce. The enthusiasm did not infect the world — the global axis stayed at neutral the whole time —, and without an external echo the impulse drained away before it could turn into structure. The intermarket reading itself was already warning: it rose only slightly, from 58.59 to 62.17, a lukewarm confirmation for a mood that was singing loud and clear.

The honest verdict

Six months later, the engine itself classified this reading as insufficient. The realized return was −0.4%, on a base of only five comparable episodes and without the Ânima axis, unavailable before 2016. The record is honest: appetite got the direction of the day right, not that of the cycle. A mood that applauds alone rarely holds the stage — and statistics, when they are shallow, authorize no conviction at all.

Continue reading: When fear stopped paying rent · The alarm that did not cross the border · Ânima versus Perene Risk — mood against appetite →

The Radar reads these regimes every day. See today's reading →

Characters: Structure (intermarket) · Flow (risk appetite) · Mood · Dollar · Cyclicals × defensives