Radar Perene / Articles / episode

The return of the poor relatives of February 2014 — the end of a punishment, not the start of a reign

Episode

The extreme

It was not enthusiasm — it was the end of a punishment. Real estate funds, the most battered asset on the exchange against the broad index, stopped taking blows and recovered almost all of their relative lag in a single month. Brick did not become fashionable; it merely stopped being the most loathed corner of the market. In numbers: the IFIX/IBOV ratio jumped from z −1.24 to −0.12 (Δ +1.11), the largest shift in the structure for the month, while the Perene Risk Index rose off January's floor, from 24.1 to 31.8 — out of the bottom, still in gloom. Selic at 10.75% per year, the dollar at R$ 2.3837.

What happened next

The return of the poor relatives founded no reign at all. In May, the money ran to another address — the Cyclical/Non-Cyclical ratio surged to z +2.64, a rare conviction in cycle-sensitive names, and brick was left behind. In August, the reversal completed: domestic appetite jumped to 68.1, but concentrated in the banks (Financials at z +3.29), and real estate funds sank to the worst spot in the series, z −2.72. The poor relatives had come back in February and, six months later, were once again at the end of the line. Only in early 2015 would brick taste a true premium — z +1.43 — before losing it once more.

What did not happen

February's recovery was not a regime change. The intermarket barely moved (54.17 to 54.08), the domestic regime stayed pinned to neutral at 52.9, and aggregate appetite never followed — 31.8 is gloom, not a rebound. Nor was there a single rush to safety: in the very month a classic defensive (brick) was rehabilitating itself, another (the utilities) was giving back ground. Each piece was judged on its own merit. This was not fear receding in a block; it was relative price correcting itself.

The honest verdict

The Radar read the month for what it was — an internal redistribution without a change of regime — and was honest about the size of the base: five comparable episodes, a sample too shallow to nail the signal. Six months later, the broad market returned +29.1%, well above what was expected, and the reading was classified as ambiguity. The hit was recognizing the end of the punishment. What slipped through was that, for brick itself, the punishment would return before the year was out.

Continue reading: When the bet becomes a lone conviction (May 2014) · The single bet on banks (August 2014) · The premium of the brick that came undone (February 2015) →

The Radar reads these regimes every day. See today's reading →

Characters: Structure (intermarket) · Flow (risk appetite) · Mood · Dollar