Radar Perene / Articles / episode

The shelter no one vacated for a year — March 2023

Episode

The extreme

The March report closed with a question that looked modest: if the ratio of cyclicals to defensives turned higher again, the month's flight to defense would have been just an episode. The market took a year to answer — and the answer was no. That month, Brazilian money made the most unambiguous gesture of the season: it dropped everything betting on the economy turning and ran for what shields against it. Utilities and real estate funds filled the shelter. In numbers: the cyclical/non-cyclical ratio collapsed from 0.32 to -1.23, a drop of 1.54 standard deviations — the largest move in the entire table of relative prices —, with IFIX climbing to 1.29 against IBOV and Utilities jumping to 0.82. The regime closed defensive, score 31.1.

What happened next

Defense was no episode; it was a change of address. Three months later, in June, mood took the opposite road and surged to extreme optimism — Ânima jumped from 46.5 to 69.2 —, but prices ignored the party: commodities in reais sank to -2.21 deviations and the intermarket returned to neutral. In September, six months on, the shelter grew even fuller: Utilities rose from 0.64 to 1.38 against IBOV, the highest point of the reading, and domestic risk crossed into risk-off. Only in March 2024, twelve months later, did the money begin to leave the corner — the cyclical/non-cyclical ratio came back from -0.27 to 0.32, returning cyclicals to the equilibrium line. A full year inside the shelter.

What did not happen

The deep pessimism of March — mood sunk to 20.6, the lowest of the series — was not the guide it seemed to be. Anyone reading it as rock bottom got it wrong twice: three months later that same mood was in euphoria, and three months on it had already given everything back to neutral. Sentiment changed its story three times in a year; the defensive structure changed none. And June's euphoria did not empty the shelter — Utilities kept rising while the investor celebrated. The return of the cyclicals, when it finally came, arrived hand in hand with pessimism, not with confidence.

The honest verdict

The March reading got the regime right: defense, and defense that lasted. But the question the report left hanging — episode or trend? — was only answered twelve months later, too late to serve as a trigger for anyone reading it in the heat of the month. The lesson of the period stands: the structure was the sober witness; mood, the witness that kept contradicting itself. When the two disagree, it is the silent corner of the shelter that tends to tell the truth — slowly.

Continue reading: The celebration the prices never signed · The money seeks the shelter, not the applause · The banks give up the seat of honor →

The Radar reads these regimes every day. See today's reading →

Characters: Structure (intermarket) · Flow (risk appetite) · Mood · Dollar