Radar Perene / Articles / episode

The shelter sold at the bottom of fear — April 2017

Episode

The extreme

The market dropped its umbrella the very moment it complained most about the rain. Domestic mood was sinking — its fourth straight month of erosion — and instead of running for cover, capital did the opposite: it dumped the shelter. Utilities, the heart of what you buy when you want to sleep soundly, took the hardest fall on the entire board. Anyone listening to the sentiment thermometer saw fear; anyone watching where the money went saw courage. In numbers: the Ânima Index fell from 36.3 to 23.0 — the most depressed point since January's 71.5 — while the intermarket climbed from 70.6 to 76.87, strong risk_on. The Utilities/IBOV ratio collapsed from −0.15 to −1.90 of deviation, the largest delta of the month, and Cyclical/Non-Cyclical stretched from +1.47 to +2.43. The Selic ended at 11.25% a year, the dollar at R$ 3.1362.

What happened next

The chasm between mood and capital did not close from the end you would expect. Sentiment, instead of stabilizing, worsened first: in June, Ânima carved out the floor of the series at 12.6. And then, in July, it leapt a full spectrum — from 12.6 to 67.9 in a single month, from entrenched gloom to extreme optimism. It was mood that ran after capital's courage, not the other way around. The defensive stayed abandoned, and Cyclical/Non-Cyclical kept stretching, to 2.19 of deviation. Months ahead the choreography would invert: in October, confidence would celebrate at the top while the structure caved in at 8.2.

What did not happen

The capital that dropped the shelter at the bottom of fear was not punished. The concentration the month flagged as "fragile" did not break right away — it deepened. And anyone who read Ânima's pessimism at 23.0 as a signal to pull out would have left right before the turn. The bottom of sentiment, in fact, was not April: it was June, lower still.

The honest verdict

The reading got the regime right — flow and mood were measuring different things, and flow was the one that was right. But timing was treacherous: mood had to sink further before it turned. Capital's courage anticipated the direction; it just didn't warn how much fear still had to drain.

Continue reading: How long mood takes to catch up to flow · The confidence the capital distrusts (Oct 2017) · Capital moves to a new neighborhood (Aug 2017) →

The Radar reads these regimes every day. See today's reading →