Radar Perene / Articles / article

The three speeds of deterioration — mood at 2.6, structure still at 56.8

Article

The extreme

A collapse does not hit every instrument on the dashboard at the same time. In March 2020, the Radar logged three gauges of the same market marking three different things — and the difference was not error, it was lag. Domestic mood was already scraping the floor; the intermarket ratios had turned to defense; the broad structure of the regime had not yet even noticed. In numbers: the Ânima Index fell from 4.1 to 2.6 (extreme pessimism), the intermarket retreated to 38.87 (moderate risk-off), and the broad Brazilian regime stayed in risk-on, at 56.8.

What happened next

The order is the lesson. Sentiment was the first to give way, the intermarket followed, and the broad structure held — because it took months to assemble and does not come undone in thirty days. In the same month, the Perene Risk Index moved from 0.0 to 10.6, but the direction was an exit from risk, not a return of appetite. The Central Bank cut the Selic to 3.75% a year with the IPCA nearly flat at 0.07%, and the dollar at R$4.8839 entered statistical anomaly. The tension April inherited was exactly that: three axes still out of alignment.

What did not happen

The structure did not break in March. Risk-on at 56.8 did not turn — and anyone waiting for the three gauges to point down together would have to wait longer. Nor was there enthusiasm where there seemed to be: Commodities/IBOV and IFIX/IBOV rose, but because the IBOV fell faster than the denominators, not out of appetite. Rising in the ratio is not the same as rising.

The honest verdict

The lag between the axes is information, not noise. Sentiment is the fastest nerve; structure, the slowest. The engine itself admitted the limit: deep fear with the exchange rate in anomaly has historically been associated with resolutions too heterogeneous to classify the regime with confidence.

Continue reading: The structure leads the mood · Was March 2020 the bottom? · The intermarket as a gauge →

The Radar reads these regimes every day. See today's reading →

Characters: Structure (intermarket) · Flow (risk appetite)