Radar Perene / Archive / article

The refuge premium: utilities only pay when growth is called into question

◦ Written under index methodology v1 (in effect until 15 Jul 2026). The current series is v2 — readings quoted here may differ from those shown today. See the methodology.

Article

The extreme

There is a sector that gains no relative ground when the market believes in the future. Utilities — power, sanitation, contracted revenue indexed to inflation — advance under only one scenario: when the investor stops trusting growth. In September 2021, that scenario arrived all at once: utilities jumped, in a single month, from ground below the ordinary to clearly above it — and they did not come alone, commodities priced in reais against the IBOV surged in the same direction. Two refuges of opposite natures rising side by side.

What happened next

The premium was not optimism in disguise. While utilities and the currency-linked real asset advanced, commodities measured in neutral currency crossed below their own ordinary and the intermarket grid fell from 44.8 to 37.47. The honest reading was not conviction in the price of iron ore; it was a coordinated withdrawal from everything that depends on domestic mood to grow. That mood, in fact, had collapsed: the Ânima Index fell from 43.8 to 9.4. When money runs, it picks shelters — and the shelter of utilities is the predictable cash flow, not the bet.

What did not happen

The utilities premium did not arise from a worsening abroad. Global risk closed neutral, at 50.2: the stress was domestic, manufactured at home by the pincer of a 6.25% annual Selic and a monthly IPCA of 1.16%. And the refuge premium did not mean a collapse of the structure — the Brazilian regime remained neutral, at 53.4. The short-term thermometer was screaming; the broad picture had not yet confirmed.

The honest verdict

The refuge premium is a sign of distrust, not of catastrophe. Utilities appreciate when the investor doubts growth — but doubting is not the same as seeing the regime turn. Reading the utilities jump as the start of a crisis would have been reading a single snapshot far too fast.

Continue reading: The money that fled inward · The dollar as a regime thermometer · When the thermometers disagree →

The Radar reads these regimes every day. See today's reading →

Characters: Cyclicals × defensives