The fear the prices didn't buy — February 2023

Episode

The extreme

The domestic investor woke up afraid. The confidence January had rebuilt collapsed in a single month, and the pessimism came back whole — but the gear of relative prices, usually less impressionable than mood, barely budged. Sentiment read threat; structure read rotation. In numbers: the Ânima Index fell from 67.6 to 26.6 and internal risk pulled back to 27.9 (risk-off), while the intermarket gave up only three points, from 66.15 to 63.01, and stayed in appetite. Underneath, capital changed neighborhoods without fleeing: the ratio between real estate funds and the Ibovespa flipped from -0.67 to +0.76, and financials rose even more (z from 1.40 to 1.85). The Selic held at 13.75% and the IPCA doubled, to 0.84%.

What happened next

The investor's fear took months to pass. In March, Ânima sank even deeper, to 20.6, and stayed stuck there until May, when it finally woke up to 46.5. But the market didn't wait for the mood. The structure that had stayed in the field of appetite was right: six months after February, the engine measured a return of 12.8% — within the central band that similar configurations produced, with a median of 10.4% — and the episode matured into a hit. The confidence thermometer screamed; it was relative prices that set the right tone.

What did not happen

The forty-point drop in mood did not turn into a stampede. There was no generalized flight from risk — there was rotation: money left the cyclicals (the ratio against defensives pulled back from 1.29 to 0.32), moved into real estate and into commodities in reais, and kept financials in the lead. Nor did the bottom of the mood mark the bottom of the market: the investor stayed depressed for another quarter while the structure was already walking toward its +12.8%. Anyone who read the fear as a verdict missed the silent rotation that was paying out underneath.

The honest verdict

This time, the structure of prices read better than the confidence thermometer. Mood is the most volatile and noisiest part of the set — it swings forty points in a month without prices validating it. But it is no oracle: months ahead, in August, it would be the risk axis that collapsed and billed the cost of the euphoria. Neither of the two rules every time. The honest record of February 2023 is that, in that month, whoever listened only to the scream of fear lost what the structure was whispering.

Continue reading: A year of discord — 2023 · When the thermometers disagree · Ânima vs Perene Risk: mood against appetite →

The Radar reads these regimes every day. See today's reading →

Characters: Mood

This is the Radar’s memory. Today’s reading — regime, 5 lenses and the day’s analogs — is live, free.

See today’s reading Explore the Founder Edition →